Why Business Owners Need a Different Kind of Estate Plan
A standard estate plan — a will, a revocable trust, and powers of attorney — is built around the assumption that your assets are liquid and divisible. A business is neither. It cannot be split among heirs the way a bank account can. It may require active management that your surviving spouse or children are not equipped to provide. And its value may be locked up in relationships, goodwill, and operational knowledge that disappears the moment you do.
Business owners need an estate plan that is built around the business: one that addresses who takes over, how a co-owner is bought out, how personal wealth is protected from business creditors, and how the IRS values the business at death. A plan that ignores any of these questions leaves the business — and the family — exposed.
The most common mistake: Business owners have a personal estate plan and a set of business documents — but the two were never coordinated. The estate plan doesn't account for the business interest, and the operating agreement doesn't address death or incapacity. The gap between them is where estates fall apart.
Business Succession Planning
Succession planning answers the question every business owner eventually faces: what happens to this business when I can no longer run it? There are three broad outcomes — and each requires different planning.
Family succession
If you want the business to pass to a child or other family member, your estate plan must ensure a smooth transfer of ownership and control. That means identifying and preparing a successor, addressing the interests of family members who are not involved in the business, and structuring the transfer in a way that minimizes estate and gift tax. Family succession also raises equity questions: if one child receives the business, how are other children treated fairly?
Key employee buyout
When a trusted employee or management team is the right successor, the succession plan needs to define the purchase price, the financing terms, and the transition of relationships and authority. This often involves a combination of a buy-sell agreement, seller financing, and life insurance to fund an immediate buyout at death.
Third-party sale
If the intent is to sell the business to an outside buyer — at death, retirement, or a future exit — the estate plan should be structured to maximize value and minimize taxes on the sale. This includes thinking about the holding structure, the timing of a sale, and how proceeds are integrated into the personal estate plan.
Buy-Sell Agreements
A buy-sell agreement is the legal mechanism that controls what happens to a co-owner's interest when they die, become disabled, retire, or leave the business. Without one, a co-owner's heirs inherit their share — and you may find yourself in business with your partner's spouse or children.
What a buy-sell agreement establishes
- Triggering events — death, disability, divorce, retirement, voluntary departure, or bankruptcy of an owner
- Valuation — a fixed price, a formula, or a process for independent appraisal at the triggering event
- Who buys — the remaining owners (cross-purchase), the business itself (entity redemption), or a hybrid of both
- Funding — typically life insurance, installment payments, or a combination
Cross-purchase vs. entity redemption
In a cross-purchase arrangement, each co-owner holds a life insurance policy on the others and uses the proceeds to buy out the deceased owner's interest directly. In an entity redemption, the business holds the policies and buys back the interest itself. The choice between them affects the surviving owners' tax basis, the number of policies required, and how the buyout interacts with the corporate structure. For businesses with multiple owners, the analysis can be complex.
Estate tax treatment under IRC § 2703
A buy-sell agreement can establish the value of your business interest for estate tax purposes — but only if it meets the three-part test under IRC § 2703. The agreement must be a bona fide business arrangement, not a device to transfer value to family members for less than full consideration, and its terms must be comparable to what unrelated parties would agree to at arm's length. An agreement that fails this test will be disregarded for estate tax valuation, leaving the IRS to set the value on its own terms. See our detailed post on buy-sell agreements under Utah law.
LLC and Corporate Structures for Asset Protection
One of the most important — and most commonly neglected — aspects of business owner estate planning is the separation of personal wealth from business liability. The structure of your business is not just a tax question; it is an asset protection question.
What an LLC actually protects
A properly maintained Utah LLC provides two distinct layers of protection. First, it shields your personal assets from business creditors — someone who sues the business generally cannot reach your home, personal bank accounts, or investments. Second, Utah's charging order statute (Utah Code § 48-3a-503) limits a personal creditor's ability to reach your LLC interest — a creditor who wins a judgment against you personally cannot simply take over your membership interest or force a liquidation of the LLC.
These protections are real, but they are not automatic. They depend on keeping business and personal finances genuinely separate, maintaining the operating agreement, and having the LLC structure set up correctly from the start. See our analysis of when an LLC protects your personal assets.
How your LLC fits into your estate plan
Your LLC membership interest is an asset of your estate. At death, it passes to whoever you have designated — through your will, your trust, or by the terms of the operating agreement itself. The operating agreement should address what happens to a member's interest at death: whether it transfers automatically, whether remaining members have a right of first refusal, and who can step into a management role. An operating agreement that is silent on these questions creates serious problems for the estate. Read more about how an LLC fits into a Utah estate plan.
Business Valuation and Estate Tax
Your business interest is included in your taxable estate at its fair market value on the date of your death. For a closely held business — one with no ready market for its shares — that value is determined by appraisal, and the IRS has its own view of what the business is worth.
Several planning strategies can legitimately reduce the taxable value of a business interest:
- Minority interest discounts — a non-controlling interest in a business is worth less than a proportional share of the whole, because a minority owner cannot force a sale or control operations
- Marketability discounts — interests in closely held businesses are harder to sell than publicly traded stock, which reduces their fair market value
- A properly structured buy-sell agreement — if it meets the IRC § 2703 requirements, the agreed price controls for estate tax purposes
- Gifting programs — transferring minority interests to family members over time, taking advantage of annual gift exclusions and applicable discounts
These strategies require careful coordination between the business structure, the buy-sell agreement, and the personal estate plan.
Coordinating Business and Personal Documents
A business owner's estate plan has two moving parts that must work together: the personal documents (will, trust, powers of attorney) and the business documents (operating agreement, shareholder agreement, buy-sell agreement). Gaps between them are the most common source of problems.
- Your revocable living trust should hold your business interest if you want to avoid probate on it — which requires re-titling the interest into the trust's name
- Your financial power of attorney should explicitly authorize your agent to manage and vote a business interest on your behalf if you become incapacitated
- Your operating agreement should give your successor trustee or personal representative the authority to step into your role without triggering a forced dissolution or buyout
- Life insurance used to fund a buy-sell agreement should be reviewed alongside your personal beneficiary designations to ensure the proceeds go where the plan requires
For more on what happens to a business when the owner becomes incapacitated without a plan, see what happens to your business if you're incapacitated.
The JD/MBA Advantage
Legal precision. Business fluency.
Paul R. Maxfield holds both a J.D. from J. Reuben Clark Law School at BYU and an MBA from Western Governors University. That combination is uncommon among estate planning attorneys — and it matters for business owner clients.
Most estate planning attorneys understand trusts and wills. Fewer understand how a business is valued, how cash flow affects a buyout structure, how equity and debt interact in a closely held company, or how a business owner's personal balance sheet relates to the business's. Paul's MBA training means he can read the business alongside the legal documents and identify the coordination issues that a purely legal analysis would miss.
For business owners, estate planning is not just a legal exercise — it is a financial one. Paul brings both to every client engagement.
What I Do for Business Owner Clients
- Design and draft buy-sell agreements — cross-purchase, entity redemption, or hybrid — coordinated with life insurance and the business structure
- Review and update operating agreements and shareholder agreements to address death, disability, and succession
- Structure the personal estate plan — will, trust, powers of attorney — to account for the business interest and prevent gaps
- Advise on LLC structure and asset protection under Utah law, including the operating agreement provisions that preserve charging order protection
- Coordinate business interests with the personal estate plan to minimize estate tax exposure and ensure a clean transfer at death
- Work with your CPA, financial advisor, and insurance professional as a coordinated team — the legal documents must align with the financial and insurance planning
Frequently Asked Questions
-
Without a succession plan, your business interest passes through your estate like any other asset — to your heirs, who may have no ability or desire to run the business. Co-owners may suddenly find themselves in business with your spouse or children. The business may have to be liquidated to settle your estate. A buy-sell agreement and a coordinated estate plan prevent all of this by establishing in advance exactly what happens and how it is funded.
-
A buy-sell agreement is a binding contract among co-owners of a business that controls what happens to an owner's interest upon death, disability, retirement, or departure. It sets the price or valuation method, the terms of purchase, and how the buyout is funded — typically through life insurance or installment payments. If you have co-owners in your business, a buy-sell agreement is not optional; without one, the ownership of your business is determined by whoever inherits your interest.
-
A properly maintained Utah LLC provides two layers of protection: it shields your personal assets from business liabilities, and Utah's charging order protection limits a personal creditor's ability to reach your LLC interest. However, these protections depend on keeping business and personal finances separate, maintaining the LLC formalities, and having the operating agreement drafted correctly. An LLC that is not properly maintained can lose its protective effect.
-
Business interests are included in your taxable estate at fair market value. For a closely held business, this requires a formal valuation — and without planning, the IRS may value your interest higher than you expect. A properly structured and funded buy-sell agreement can establish the value of your interest for estate tax purposes, provided it meets the requirements of IRC § 2703. Minority and marketability discounts may also apply depending on the structure.
-
You need one coordinated plan that covers both. Your personal estate plan — your will, trust, and powers of attorney — must account for how your business interest passes, who has authority to manage it if you become incapacitated, and how it is valued and taxed at your death. And your business documents — the operating agreement or shareholder agreement, any buy-sell agreement — must align with your personal plan. Gaps between the two documents are where estates fall apart.